Skip to main content
October 2, 2026

Canada's Pension Funds Are Not Normal

The National Interest

Last week, we published a policy report, suggesting that Canada’s biggest pension funds should be mandated to put 3 per cent of their assets into real Canadian growth.

Globe and Mail columnist Andrew Coyne called it a “really really really bad idea.”

Coyne had a bit more to say about it in his column this week. It’s fair to say that he’d rather see pensions move to passive management, with minimal administrative overhead.

More broadly, Coyne is clearly opposed to the kind of economic policy that deliberately aims to strengthen Canada’s economy. His preferred approach is an economic policy rooted in 1990s-style free trade agreements and minimal government intervention.

Suffice it to say, we really, really, really disagree with Coyne about this. It’s not the 1990s anymore, and the economic and geopolitical realities of 2026 are vastly different.

We believe that the massive pools of capital controlled by the big Canadian pension funds can do more to help grow ambitious Canadian companies. Maybe Taalas would still be Canadian, or Xanadu’s success could have benefited more Canadians if we did.

Critics treat it as sacrosanct that pension funds can only exist as fully independent entities with a fiduciary duty to maximize returns. But the truth is that the fiduciary duty is, itself, a mandate from the government; these funds are creatures of public policy, and we can have a debate about how they should operate.

It’s also strange that defenders of the status quo treat it as a fact of nature that Canadian pension funds would invest very little in Canada. It wasn’t that long ago that we had the Foreign Property Rule which prevented Canadian pensions from investing more than 30 per cent of assets abroad.

Wherever you fall on this debate, it’s important to understand that the hands-off, laissez-faire approach to pension investing is not the only model.

Take a look at where Canada’s pensions sit among the largest 100 pension funds in the world, in terms of overall domestic investment:

Our proposal that pension funds should be mandated to invest 3 per cent of assets in high-growth Canadian companies is modest.

We don’t need to do a tour of the whole world to illustrate the point; we just need to look at Norway.

Norway has two big public pension funds, with confusingly similar names:

  • Government Pension Fund Global
  • Government Pension Fund Norway

The first one, the Government Pension Fund Global is the world’s largest sovereign wealth fund, and it invests only abroad. It’s currently worth about US$2.2 trillion. The fund is meant to act as a hedge against oil and the domestic economy.

The second fund, the Government Pension Fund Norway, invests close to home: split 60 per cent equities, 40 per cent bonds, with 85 per cent in Norway and 15 per cent in the rest of the Nordic region. It’s the largest institutional investor on the Oslo Stock Exchange, holding more than 11 per cent of it. As a patient, long-term shareholder, it gives a small market stability and liquidity while also acting as an engaged owner of Norwegian companies. Norway’s bond market benefits, too.

This domestic fund is less than 2 per cent of Norway’s combined public funds.

This is not far from what we’re proposing, albeit our version is much more tightly targeted to high-growth Canadian companies whose success would strengthen Canada’s trade capacity — diversifying not just our export markets, but crucially, diversifying the products and services we sell to the world.

And here’s the funny thing about the Norway experience: it works. The domestic fund has returned 8.09 per cent a year over the past decade, and its active management beat its benchmark by 0.88 percentage points a year. Norway shows that a small, dedicated, openly mandated domestic allocation can sit alongside a global portfolio and perform well.

In Norway, Parliament and the Finance Ministry set the benchmarks openly, and the managers carry them out. Everyone in Norway has a stake and an incentive to build a stronger economy.

Meanwhile Canada is still clinging to this idea of a laissez-faire world, where we all trade freely and nobody abuses their power. Increasingly, it feels like some people are clinging to a world that no longer exists — maybe a world that never truly was.

The world’s economy has changed.

We think it’s high time to create the conditions to build and scale in Canada.

More from Shield

The Morning After The Budget: What's Canada's Sovereign Company Strategy?

Canada and the EU Can Be Friends With Benefits

Ever since Prime Minister Mark Carney visited the European Parliament in September, we’ve been thinking about what a deeper alliance across the Atlantic Ocean could mean. As we hit send on this email, Carney is meeting with António Costa, President of the European Council, and Ursula von der Leyen, President of the European Commission, in Montreal. At the end of it all, we’re expecting an announcement of … something. There have been a lot of anonymous tips in news reporting, but at the Canadian Shield Institute, we prefer to read the formal communiqué rather than trying to interpret whispers. In the run-up to the summit, we’ve been doing a bit of research, and we published a few articles to set the stage.

EU Media Marketplace

The Europeans are trying to break the AdTech duopoly. Canadian companies have tried to work together to create an alternative to Google and Meta’s dominance. So far, Canada’s efforts have fallen flat. Will this new EU enterprise fare any better? Read our analysis here.

We find this whole situation very interesting for two reasons: First, Canada and Europe have a lot of the same problems right now. We’re all trying to figure out how to reduce vulnerability from the United States, and that vulnerability extends to digital reliance on private-sector technology platforms. It seems like we could benefit by joining forces, but it’s going to take some work figuring out exactly what that looks like in practice. Second, AdTech is just really interesting! Programmatic targeted advertising is the economic engine of the internet, and in turn this kind of advertising is hugely influential on culture and society. AdTech dictates what kinds of businesses thrive and what kinds of content gets posted online. Once you start researching it, AdTech quickly starts to look like one of the most important dimensions of digital sovereignty. If the online economy is entirely dominated by systems controlled by a handful of big American technology companies, realistically both Canada and the EU will always be on the back foot on digital governance.

Digital Services Trade

Speaking of being on the back foot, did you know that U.S. digital services exports to Canada are worth more than all the autos, steel, aluminum, lumber, potash and electricity put together? Why aren’t we talking about digital trade policy more in the negotiations with the United States? Read our analysis here.

And the European Union is in a similar position. The EU has done a lot more to assert digital governance, but their trade deficit on digital services just keeps going up. This is a kind of reliance that creates a meaningful vulnerability if the United States keeps playing hardball. Read our analysis about EU digital trade here.

Digital services might be a promising area for Canada and the European Union to work together. When the final communiqué is delivered from the Canada-EU summit, we will be combing through it for specific mentions of digital trade collaboration.

Digital Sovereignty Policy

Despite the EU’s digital dependence, we see a lot to admire in how the Europeans have been trying to assert their digital sovereignty. To be blunt: They’re trying things! Canada has often been slow to pass meaningful digital regulation, and quick to walk back policies that offend the Americans. The EU has enacted some really interesting regulations. Could Canada use “digital trade alignment” as cover to follow the EU’s lead? Read our analysis here.

The Bottom Line

Overall, when it comes to digital governance, we have a lot of hard work ahead of us. Digital policy is complicated and opaque, and it’s not enough to just pass a good law. Ongoing enforcement is a real challenge too. But this is one of the most pressing policy issues of our time, and with the accelerating deployment of AI systems, this issue is only going to become more urgent. It’s not as easy as striking a deal to sell soybeans, but digital governance is an area where Canada and the EU are natural partners, and it’s something we should be working on.

Read the article

The Spooky Intangible Assets That Haunt our Economy

Don’t Miss an Update,
Subscribe to
Newsletter
Subscribe to receive our weekly newsletter that include reports, updates and much more.
Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required

Newsletter

By subscribing, you agree to our Privacy Policy.
You can unsubscribe at any time.